Aaron Rodgers, Derek Carr, Green Bay Packers, Las Vegas Raiders, New York Jets
Aaron Rodgers, Derek Carr, Green Bay Packers, Las Vegas Raiders, New York Jets, Getty Images

It’s time to go all-in on 2023

What happens if the New York Jets miss out on the future Hall of Famer?

The New York Jets have an uncanny ability to plug themselves in some uncomfortable spots. After the 2022 season affirmed the fact that Zach Wilson is not (at least for the foreseeable future) the guy to lead Robert Saleh’s squad to the promised land, New York is once again on the lookout for a signal caller.

And the said search is once again the main topic of the Jets’ offseason.

Aaron Rodgers, Derek Carr, and Jimmy Garopolo seem to be the three main targets, be it via trade or the open market.

Rodgers, 39, is a first-ballot Hall of Famer with an unquestioned resumé. Carr, a former second-round pick, seems to be the favorite option from a cost-benefit perspective. Jimmy G, in his turn, is perceived as a system QB who won’t find success away from Kyle Shanahan.

The Jets have already made clear which scheme they are going to run after hiring Nathaniel Hackett, the former Denver Broncos head coach and Rodgers’s former coordinator, to be the team’s offensive coordinator.

Hackett, 43, is a coach with an unimpressive resumé: his best days came in Jacksonville, coaching the 2017 offense that made it to the AFC Championship Game with Blake Bortles under center. His days in Green Bay come with an asterisk, as former offensive coordinator Matt LaFleur called the plays and probably was deeply involved with game planning.

Bottom line: Hackett is a settled coach who’s bounced around and has never been “exceptional.” He’s not a coach that will help elevate the unit’s ceiling.

After hiring Hackett, something became even clearer: despite the optimism surrounding Carr, when considering the New York Jets’ particular context, the soon-to-be former Raider is closer to Garapolo than he is to Rodgers.

Carr, 31, comes with more question marks than Jets fans want to think.

First, Carr has never played on the East Coast: his high school and college days passed in California, while he only played for the Raiders (Oakland, Las Vegas) in the NFL. Does Carr even want to play in the New York cold while also having to travel to Buffalo and New England every year?

Second, yes, Carr has had four seasons with over 4,000 passing yards, and he has posted better overall numbers than Garoppolo. But one has to keep in mind that the same circumstances that might stop Carr from having team success help him reach better individual stats: the Raiders’ bad defenses made Carr play catch-up football often. When you look into Carr’s four 4,000-yard seasons, three of them came with negative or even records (4-12, 2008; 7-9, 2019; 8-8, 2020).

Third, after the Hackett hiring, It’s safe to say that Carr has never played on the scheme that the Jets will deploy.

All in all: the prospect of Carr’s success in New York is more uncertain than fans want to think.

Garoppolo, on the other hand, might be lifted due to the specific New York Jets context: he’s played in cold weather in college (Eastern Illinois) and early in his New England career. He’s got scheme familiarity with Hackett, who, like Kyle Shanahan (albeit not nearly as well), wants to manufacture open space over the middle on play-action throws, at which Garoppolo excels.

Also, despite never having thrown for over 4,000 yards (he did throw for 3,978 in 2019 when the 49ers had a 13-3 record), Garoppolo has played his entire career under a scheme that relies on the ground game and with a good defense on his back, which depressed his passing numbers.

Garoppolo’s major question mark is health: he played a full season only once, in 2019, and has suffered from numerous injuries over the past few seasons. Still, portraying him as a major downgrade to Derek Carr is not true.

A word of caution: This article doesn’t say Garoppolo is as good as Carr. He is not. Carr is an above-average-to-good quarterback, while Garoppolo is an average player. But he’s not as far behind as many people think.

Football fans have to understand that there’s something in between the “great” and the “bad,” and that’s where both Garoppolo and Carr are. Neither of them has to be pushed to either category: Carr isn’t great; Garoppolo isn’t bad. One is an average quarterback (Garoppolo) and the other is an above-average quarterback (Carr).

Considering the Jets’ context, It’s fair to wonder if those guys aren’t even closer to each other than the isolated tape watch might indicate.

Rodgers, unquestionably, has all the tools needed: the resumé, the scheme familiarity with Hackett, and has played his whole career in the Green Bay cold.

Rodgers’ cost is his only minus: it might be pricey. Still, It’s hard to think of a value that wouldn’t make it worthwhile for all parties involved on the Jets’ side.

For Saleh and Joe Douglas, it increases the likelihood of keeping their jobs. To fans, it’s the most concrete hope for the team’s first playoff win since the 2010 season (and, who knows, maybe even the Super Bowl). For Woody Johnson, it means full stadiums and a lot of media attention – which is everything the Jets owner could hope for.

But if Rodgers says no… Well, the Jets will have to forget the great and live with the average, no matter if Jimmy G or Derek Carr comes aboard: average expectations, average play at the quarterback position, and, for Woody, average attendance.

It would put extra pressure on Douglas to build a competitive roster and Saleh to coach his players up.

Quarterback play-wise, it will certainly be better than what 2022 had for them. Still, Saleh might want to keep Mike White around. Who knows … just in case.

Audio Version available to members only: Learn more here

Download Jet X Mobile on the App Store and Google Play.

Want More NY Jets News & Jets X-Factor Content?

Download the free Jet X Mobile App to get customizable notifications directly to your iOS (App Store) or Google/Android (Google Play) device.

Add Jets X-Factor to your Google News feed to stay up to date with the New York Jets.

Follow us on Twitter @jetsxfactor for all the latest New York Jets news, Facebook for even more, Instagram for some of the top NY Jets images, and YouTube for original Jets X-Factor videos.

Join the official Jets Discord community to connect with likeminded fans.

A former quarterback, Vitor Paiva wants to showcase a deep analysis of what's really happening on the field, showcasing what's really on the mind of a football player during a play, in his Sidearm Session. Email: vitorpaivagon[at]gmail.com
5 1 vote
Article Rating
Notify of
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
7 months ago

Thank you for being a voice of reason about the QB position in general and telling the truth about Carr. People have been trying to portray him as a comparable option to Rodgers when he’s actually much more comparable to Jimmy G or Tannehill, but with a much higher risk factor in terms of his contract. Fans are so desperate for hope that they’re willing to ignore that his ability relative to his contract is a potential nightmare waiting to happen. The only comfort I have about the situation is that I can’t see this regime making such a reckless move. 

Harlan Lachman
Harlan Lachman
7 months ago

I found this a silly, impatient, and depressing article. I hope the Jets ignore this advice. I am tired of SOJ stupidity. More than 50 years has been too long to wait. The damage to the roster to carry the salary and the lost opportunity to fix important problems through the draft are worth avoiding, as is Rodgers.

Peter Buell
Peter Buell
7 months ago

Without a first rounder this year and little cap space unless they strip more than just the players that make sense both from how much can be saved and is that player not needed on the team.
The Jets cam get up to $47m in cap space if both Lawson and JFM are cut…if one re-structurers it’s better otherwise it’s mainly kids at EDGE.
Continuing, Davis, Whitehead and Brown get us to $47.
JD will need to be smart. Ik Rodgers was injured and had little WR help till the 2nd half of the season but he looked far from a multiple MVP winner. He looked off and disinterested.
How will ANY QB have success without a line and without a 1st round pick and cap space Rodgers will have AVT and possibly Bechton that 2bd half Jets QBs didn’t have last year…Is that enough to package the future into a two year window.
I’d prefer Carr, if possible and close the holes

7 months ago

Hey Vitor, maybe you and nania can have some sort of debate on Carr v Jimmy G. You’re both excellent and seem to completely disagree on where they rank.