Look, we get it: The New York Jets stink.
And they’ve stunk for a very long time.
Since the Jets last made the playoffs in 2010โwhen there were only three MCU filmsโevery other NFL franchise has made the dance multiple times. That includes other notoriously woeful franchises like the Cleveland Browns and the Arizona Cardinals.
So, no, the franchise generally does not deserve the benefit of the doubt when it comes to their decision-making.
What they deserve, though, is to be analyzed with the same degree of nuance as every other NFL franchise. After all, for as embarrassing as their playoff drought may be, let’s not forget this: over the last 30 years, the Jets still have more AFC championship appearances than the rival Buffalo Bills and Miami Dolphins… combined.
Miami has not even won a playoff game since the first year of the 21st century.
The Jets might be a lowly NFL franchise, but they’re still an NFL franchise. So, when national media pundits choose to use the Jets as a platform to spew off outlandish opinions, thinking that the world will laugh along with them, all it really does is expose the laziness of their analysis.
The latest viral take about the Jets is a perfect example. In a clip from “The Athletic Football Show” posted to X, which has been viewed over 210,000 times in one day, as of this writing, it is suggested that the Jets should… trade a first-round pick for Indianapolis Colts head coach Shane Steichen.
Yes, the same Shane Steichen who has a 28-34 record as a head coach, has never been to the playoffs in four years, and is likely about to be fired.
In fairness to Steichen, his record in Indianapolis, especially this season, might not be an accurate indicator of the coach he is. The Colts have had immense trouble building their roster, hence the firing of general manager Chris Ballard earlier this season. Steichen is a respected offensive mind who has had to navigate a difficult situation.
However, the 28-34 record still belongs to him. At the end of the day, he has coached four seasons and will have failed to make the playoffs a single time. That doesn’t mean he cannot be a successful head coach in the future with a fresh start, but it absolutely means that he isn’t worth giving up a single asset for, let alone a first-round pick.
The last head coach to be traded was Sean Payton, who netted a first-round pick for New Orleans when he was acquired by Denver (New Orleans also swapped a third-rounder for a second-rounder). Payton was a Super Bowl champion with a 152-89 regular season record. That’s mildly more success than Steichen.
Before Payton, the last coach to be traded was Bruce Arians, who headed from Arizona to Tampa Bay. The price was measly: a sixth-for-seventh pick swap. Yet, Arians had an impressive 49-30-1 record in Arizona, and even he could only net such a small package.
If that’s what Arians was worth, how is Steichen worth a darn thing?
Suggesting that the Jets should trade anything for Steichen would be outrageous, let alone a first-rounder. After all, if the Jets want to consider hiring him, they can just wait for him to be fired and interview him. The whole concept is so obscenely ridiculous that it is hard to fathom it could be conceived for any other reason besides reaction-baiting.
And that, my friends, is all the national media really uses the Jets for.
In that regard, success! They got reactions in this case. Good job.
But in the process, it also reveals the laziness of national media members who choose to dip their toes into Jets football. Nobody expects pundits who cover the entire league to have an opinion on Jelani Woods’ in-line blocking or whether Malachi Moore deserves third-safety snaps, but it should be a basic requirement for analysts with a large platform to offer opinions about the team that are at least semi-valuable.
“But it’s the Jets! They would do something like that!”
No, they wouldn’t.
Nobody can dispute the lengthiness of the Jets’ list of follies over the year; they deserve the flak they receive. But even they wouldn’t do something as bonkers as trade a first-round pick for a lame-duck head coach who has never made the playoffs.
As bad as the Jets have been over the last 16 seasons, their woes are more so the byproduct of poor execution than laughable thought processes. They have accrued a long list of moves that were backed by a thought process ranging from decent to surprisingly prudent but were poorly executed or failed to pan out simply due to misfortune. Few to none of their roster or regime moves over the last 16 years were universally viewed as inexcusably egregious at the time they were made, at least nowhere close to the extent that trading a first-rounder for Steichen would be (the Adam Gase hire comes the closest… but they didn’t give up anything to get him).
While it is easy to laugh at many of the Jets’ blunders in hindsight, most of them had some degree of credibility at the time. They have just managed to stumble into a shockingly steady chain of consecutive failures. None of those failures, though, were due to moves that even a seven-year-old fan would never consider making.
The national media can keep throwing jabs at the green-and-white punching bag for clicks all they want, and they’ll be successful, as the Jets’ fanbase is large and passionate; as you’d expect from a market as massive and hard-nosed as New York. But they should realize that in the process of using downright comical logic to clown on the Jets, the only ones wearing facepaint are themselves.

