During the New York Jets’ 31-12 beating at the hands of the Buffalo Bills, the same issues prevailed: big penalties and struggles to finish in the red zone. However, there was a look at someone new, as fourth-round rookie quarterback Cade Klubnik made his NFL debut in the second half.

After taking a rough hit in the second quarter, Geno Smith left the game with an ankle injury and returned for one third-quarter possession before being ruled out for the rest of the game.

Jets fans who wanted to “Open the Klub” got their first look at the fourth-round rookie, even if it wasn’t intentional. How did Klubnik fare throughout his first half in the regular season?

Evaluating Klubnik’s outing

On 26 dropbacks, Klubnik completed 11 of his 20 pass attempts (55% completion rate), throwing for 140 yards, zero touchdowns, and an interception. He also did some work on the ground, rushing for 26 yards on three attempts.

The rookie showed some encouraging flashes. On his first pass of the game, he found Garrett Wilson for 29 yards, showing nice touch on a deep corner route, dropping the ball into Wilson’s arms between two defenders. It was the type of pro-level throw that cannot be overlooked; he certainly has an NFL-caliber arm.

Klubnik also flashed his mobility; three plays after the completion to Wilson, he moved the chains on third-and-6 with a nice scramble, before picking up another first down with his legs on the following play. It was a change of pace for Jets fans who have been watching a traditional pocket passer in Smith.

While there were some clear flashes of positive traits, it was obvious that Klubnik was making his debut in several areas. Most notably, he held the ball far too long. Klubnik took three sacks on his 26 dropbacks, and his 3.55-second average time to throw was the second-highest among QBs this week before Monday Night Football, trailing only Drew Lock of the Seattle Seahawks (3.58).

It’s clear that Klubnik needs to improve at getting the ball out quickly, navigating the pocket, and avoiding sacks. There is more to that facet of the game than just escaping with mobility. Too often, he held onto the football, waiting for something to develop.

There is also the turnover component. Klubnik’s interception was a particularly poor decision. While he was pressured, he threw the ball directly into the chest of Davison Igbinosun before Jeremy Ruckert jarred the ball loose, and the Jets recovered, bailing out the rookie.

That wasn’t the only time that Klubnik put the ball in danger, either, as he was tagged for two turnover-worthy throws. Klubnik finished Sunday with a 7.7% turnover-worthy play rate, the second-highest among QBs before SNF and MNF, trailing only fellow rookie Carson Beck of the Arizona Cardinals (8.0%).

Criticizing Klubnik for his mistakes on Sunday would be outrageous. He is a Day 3 rookie who was thrown into the fire midgame to make his NFL debut against a team that entered the game at 7-1. That’s no easy task.

It would also be unfair to say it was all bad. You could see the arm capabilities, and the mobility certainly creates intrigue. But there is also plenty to clean up, and that’s expected.

Should the Jets turn the keys over to Klubnik?

Sunday served as a perfect reminder to Jets fans who were clamoring for the team to replace Smith with Klubnik. The question now is the same as it was before: what could Klubnik show over the final seven games that would change the team’s plans in the offseason?

Furthermore, the Jets could also risk sabotaging the development of the team’s young weapons, which should be the organization’s priority for the rest of the season. For those who were expecting Klubnik to step in today and lead a comeback win, or now expect him to play at a high level in seven starts, it’s unfair to the rookie.

Klubnik doesn’t deserve to be held to that standard. He was a Day 3 pick who entered the season looking to sit and develop behind a veteran in Smith, and he has done just that so far.

Now that he has something on film in the regular season, it should help him go back to the drawing board and find out where he needs to improve. That’s also something else to keep in mind. Not only was he thrown in to start the second half, but second-team QBs don’t get many reps in practice throughout the week.

Ultimately, Klubnik’s showing on Sunday shouldn’t change Jets fans’ outlook on him for better or worse. It went exactly as expected.

Maybe the Jets revisit the conversation of starting him after their Week 13 bye, unless Smith’s injury forces him into the starting lineup, of course.