Home | Articles | Analytics | 3 options for NY Jets to replace injured DT Sheldon Rankins

3 options for NY Jets to replace injured DT Sheldon Rankins

NY Jets, Visit, Linval Joseph, Free Agent, Sign, Rumors, Stats
Linval Joseph, New York Jets, Los Angeles Chargers, Getty Images

New York Jets must figure out a short-term solution to replace Sheldon Rankins

New York Jets defensive tackle Sheldon Rankins suffered a dislocated elbow in the team’s Week 9 win over the Buffalo Bills. Per ESPN’s Jeremy Fowler, Rankins could miss up to 4-6 weeks.

Head coach Robert Saleh said Rankins is week-to-week and that the team hopes it can avoid placing him on injured reserve (which would keep him out a minimum of four weeks).

Rankins is having a strong season for New York. The veteran has been active as both a pass rusher and run defender, collecting 14 pressures, two sacks, and 11 run stops in nine games.

How will the Jets replace Rankins while they wait for him to heal? They have plenty of options. Let’s discuss a few of them.

Before getting into the Jets’ options, it is important to understand exactly who the Jets are trying to replace here. What is Rankins’s role in the Jets’ defense?

What is Sheldon Rankins’s role?

Rankins is the left-side defensive tackle for the Jets’ starting defensive line, playing opposite Quinnen Williams, who starts at right defensive tackle. Rankins rarely moves off the left side of the line, as he has played 88.3% of his defensive snaps on the left side this season.

Rankins plays just about every position on the interior defensive line, although he mostly plays 2i-technique (over guard’s inside shoulder) and 4i-technique (over tackle’s inside shoulder).

The Jets trust Rankins to play a fairly large number of snaps. Over the first eight games of the season, Rankins was averaging 39.3 defensive snaps per game. He played about 57% of the Jets’ defensive snaps on average. Each of these numbers ranked second among the Jets’ interior defensive linemen, trailing only Williams.

Solomon Thomas and Nathan Shepherd serve as the Jets’ second-string defensive tackles. Thomas backs up Rankins on the left side while Shepherd backs up Williams on the right.

Rankins’s absence will likely result in more playing time for Thomas and Shepherd; particularly Thomas since he is Rankins’s backup on the left side. Against Buffalo, Thomas ended up playing a season-high 44% of the snaps due to Rankins’s early exit (Rankins exited after playing only 10 snaps).

But the Jets didn’t rely solely on Thomas to overtake Rankins’s vacated snaps on the left side. Shepherd also played a season-high 37% of the snaps. The Jets had him pitch in to replace Rankins by giving him more left-side snaps than usual. Shepherd played six snaps on the left side against Buffalo after playing only three over his first eight games.

I would expect Thomas and Shepherd to see larger roles going forward, but they certainly won’t eat up all 39 of the snaps per game that are left open by Rankins. Someone else is going to join them in replacing Rankins.

Let’s look at a few different ways the Jets can disperse the rest of Rankins’s snaps.

1. Sign Linval Joseph

The Jets hosted veteran defensive tackle Linval Joseph for a visit back on October 21. No deal was reached, but Joseph remains on the market as of November 8.

Joseph, 34, has 12 seasons of experience in the NFL. He most recently played for the Los Angeles Chargers in 2021, when he showed he still has plenty of gas left in the tank as he tied for 16th among defensive tackles with 27 run stops.

I do wonder if Joseph is an ideal fit for the Jets’ scheme. Joseph weighs in at 329 pounds and is not known for being the greatest athlete. He’s more of a space-eater while the Jets’ scheme typically favors smaller, more athletic defensive tackles who can shoot gaps and get after the quarterback.

It’s also worth noting that Joseph has spent a lot of time in the NFL as a pure nose tackle, whereas the Jets are looking to replace Rankins’s impact at the 2i-technique and 4i-technique positions. Joseph has occasionally played at these positions, but it’s not his bread and butter.

Despite these concerns, New York made the effort to bring Joseph in for a visit, so the team surely thinks there is some sort of role for him in the defense. Perhaps the Jets give Joseph a call back.

2. Push John Franklin-Myers inside

The Jets have used John Franklin-Myers both inside and outside this season, although the edge remains his primary home. Franklin-Myers has played 29.9% of his snaps on the interior and 70.1% on the edge. Most of those interior snaps come in obvious passing situations.

Perhaps with Rankins out, the Jets could push Franklin-Myers inside more often while giving his vacated edge snaps to a pair of youngsters who are deserving of more reps: Jermaine Johnson and Bryce Huff.

Franklin-Myers is already used to playing on the left side of the defensive line, as he’s played 95.9% of his defensive snaps on the left side this year. He plays Rankins’s position in obvious passing situations. So, kicking inside wouldn’t require a significant adjustment. He’d just be doing it more often.

Johnson is capable of overtaking Franklin-Myers’s edge reps in the Jets’ base defense. The rookie is a reliable run defender who can be trusted on early downs. Huff, meanwhile, deserves a shot to prove he can maintain his pass-rush efficiency over a larger sample of snaps.

3. Call up Tanzel Smart or Jonathan Marshall

The Jets have a pair of intriguing defensive tackles on their practice squad in Tanzel Smart and Jonathan Marshall. Rankins’s injury could pave the way for one of them to get their first snaps of the season.

Smart is already 28 years old, but it feels like he may have some untapped potential, as he looked excellent in back-to-back preseasons for the Jets. Over six preseason games from 2021 to 2022, Smart had 13 pressures, two sacks, 16 total tackles, and zero missed tackles. He shows good snap timing and impressive explosiveness off the ball; two traits that should make him an ideal scheme fit.

It feels like New York might have something in Smart. In each of the past two seasons, I was surprised when Smart did not make the team’s opening-week roster.

Marshall was chosen by the Jets in the sixth round of the 2021 draft. He only played four games as a rookie and showed very little, recording one pressure and two tackles over 77 defensive snaps. Marshall also had a missed tackle and a penalty.

In the 2022 preseason, Marshall failed to make a strong enough impression to crack the Jets’ opening-week roster. He only had one pressure and five tackles (with one missed tackle) in three games despite playing 82 snaps.

However, Marshall does offer tantalizing upside thanks to his historically great athleticism. His Relative Athletic Score (RAS) was 9.99 out of 10, the second-best mark in league history for a defensive tackle prospect. But the Jets have given Marshall plenty of opportunities to prove he can translate that athleticism into on-field impact. He hasn’t been able to do it.

Still, Marshall is a sixth-round pick who is only in his second year, so the Jets might not be ready to give up on him just yet.

The Jets are going to need a fourth defensive tackle on the roster while Rankins is gone. Unless they sign Joseph or commit to using Franklin-Myers on the inside full-time, it seems likely that either Smart or Marshall will be called up. I’m curious to see who the Jets choose.

Want More Jet X?

Subscribe to become a Jet X Member to unlock every piece of Jets X-Factor content (film breakdowns, analytics, Sabo with the Jets, etc.), get audio versions of each article, receive the ability to comment within our community, and experience an ad-free platform experience.

Download the free Jet X Mobile App to get customizable notifications directly to your iOS (App Store) or Android (Google Play) device.

Sign up for Jet X Daily, our daily newsletter that's delivered to your inbox every morning at 8:00 a.m. ET.

Add Jets X-Factor to your Google News feed and/or find us on Apple News to stay updated with the New York Jets.

Follow us on X (Formerly Twitter) @jetsxfactor for all the latest New York Jets news, Facebook for even more, Instagram for some of the top NY Jets images, and YouTube for original Jets X-Factor videos.

Related Articles

About the Author

More From Author


0 0 votes
Article Rating
Notify of
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
1 year ago

I agree with Peter about the trading of Jacob Martin. In essence, we lost a backup in order to move up one slot in a draft. You can never have enough quality backups – I didn’t like the trade then, and worse now.

1 year ago

It’s difficult to know how the staff feels about JFM against the run based on having so many better options to avoid doing it (which does shed some light).
I think bringing up Smart, giving JFM some inside reps, and giving JJ the bulk of run downs at LDE is the best response. Huff at LDE on 3rd and 4+ yd situations.
It would be nice to have a Linval Joseph type on the roster if for nothing else to stop QB sneaks…it was just too easy for Allen to lean across for yards.

Peter Buell
1 year ago
Reply to  mlesko73

Excellent point on the sneaks. Jets D has been winning on quickness, not necessarily size so it would be nice to have him in those short situations.

1 year ago

They don’t need to sign anyone. The answer is right there but they’re so damned stubborn. JFM should be inside, period. Huff is a better pass rusher, I’m sorry. Every time he’s on the field he makes something happen. JJ deserves more time as well. That line should be Huff, JFM, Williams, and either Lawson or JJ. Problem solved and you still have Solomon, Shepherd, and Curry as fill ins. Plus whoever is rotating in and out between Lawson and JJ. It’s mind boggling how they can’t see this.

Peter Buell
1 year ago

As soon as they traded Martin for as close to nothing as possible I knew there would be an injury. Not same position but he would help inside or at least someone who has familiarity with the system

1 year ago

This seems like an “in-house” problem to solve. They have the “bodies” and flexibility, guys are going to have to step up and adjust their roles. That may mean bringing someone up off the practice squad for some snaps. Rankins was having a good year, he’ll be missed but it’s time to show off the DL depth they have been shouting from the rooftops.

I think Linval Joseph makes sense ONLY in this regard: as good as the Jets’ DL is, they are a bit “light.” They might want some beef should they get deeper into this season thinking they are headed for the tournament for those big goal line stands or 4th and short stuffs.

Matt Galemmo
1 year ago

I didn’t realize Smart was 28. If he was 25 seeing what he can do would have a lot more appeal.

Joseph doesn’t sound like a fit, I’d think JFM would get more time on the interior with the bulk of Rankin’s snaps going to JJ and Huff, and although it’s probably too late for Smart to be more than JAG he becomes depth behind JFM and Thomas. I understand Rankins was playing really well, but this could be a wash for the short term and beneficial for the long term.

That said, with what’s happened since the Dolphins’ game, I trust Saleh and Ulbrich now (what a novel concept!) so JFM inside on run downs must really present a problem. I mean, look at all they’ve done to avoid it, by passing on a very attractive salary cap option to keep a player (Rankins) that was objectively awful last year. Am I reading into that? I don’t think so.

What happened to the Clemens inside experiment? Is it not even an option?

1 year ago

If you want to party, bet on Smarty!

verge tibbs
1 year ago

Yea i think theyll call up tanzel Smart, give him a shot. They didnt keep him on the ps at 28 yrs old just to take up a spot, i dont think. Ideally he gets in there and keeps the job, since i dont think they have rankins after this season.