Home | Articles | Column | NY Jets’ time for a QB switch has come — but which one?

NY Jets’ time for a QB switch has come — but which one?

Tim Boyle, New York Jets
Tim Boyle, New York Jets, Getty Images

The New York Jets’ circumstances will never be more in the backup quarterback’s favor

Stop trying to make Zach Wilson happen for the New York Jets. He’s not going to happen.

On Sundays (and Mondays), those who wear green have been personally victimized by Wilson, whose continued presence center reflects the reveal of another “Mean Girls” sequel: repetitive, offering nothing new, and longing for the glory days of 2004.

Yet, the Jets continue to place Wilson at the wheel of their rudderless, Aaron Rodgers-less offensive ship and have no apparent intentions of setting a new course. Wilson was 33-of-49 for 263 yards in the Jets’ Monday loss to the Los Angeles Chargers. He didn’t turn the ball over through the air but lost two fumbles, which yielded 14 Southern California points.

“There’s some good, some bad that he can build off of,” Robert Saleh remarked of Wilson’s latest dud, per transcripts from the Jets. “I thought, overall, he was distributing the ball… We were moving it at times… Presence in the pocket for every quarterback in football can always be a little bit better, but, like I said, he could be a lot better.”

“It’s lazy to just put it all on him. I think like I said, it was a very, it was collective all the way across the board.”

Saleh is undoubtedly right: Rodgers, Patrick Mahomes, or Tom Brady himself would have trouble succeeding behind the Jets’ makeshift offensive line. Aside from Wilson, the Jets’ imports from the NFC North (i.e., Dalvin Cook, Allen Lazard, Randall Cobb) have struggled to make any lasting difference, and even beloved franchise cornerstones like Garrett Wilson (fumbling the Jets’ second possession away) aren’t exempt from scrutiny.

But Zach Wilson hasn’t done anything to justify the Jets’ continued, if inexplicable, faith in him. While it’s almost refreshing to see a team stand by an embattled thrower in an era where patience with high-profile quarterbacks is at its thinnest (e.g., Josh Rosen, Trey Lance), the Jets can’t afford any more offensive no-shows.

Timmy Time!

Of course, if the immediate depth behind Rodgers is Wilson, one can only imagine what lies beneath Wilson. It’s certainly not pretty: Tim Boyle is 0-3 in a trio of showcases with Detroit, and the nomadic Immaculate Grid darling Trevor Siemian lingers on the practice squad.

Whether or not the Jets did enough to bolster the passing game is a discussion for another day. With the hand they’ve been dealt, though, the best card to play is undoubtedly Boyle.

The Jets threw themselves a party on offense but the guest of honor got into an accident on the way over, rendering the decor and activities awkward and uncomfortable. Even though Cobb was inactive against the Chargers, the Jets continue to insist on keeping Lazard as a top target despite some exciting young projects (Xavier Gipson) lingering behind him. Shouldn’t they at least try to see what Boyle, a two-season collaborator with Lazard, has to offer instead of the familiar endeavors of Wilson?

As an undrafted free agent of Green Bay’s in 2018 (lasting until 2020) and a camp body with the Jets this past summer, Boyle’s NFL career could realistically be described as being Rodgers’ stunt double. Between adding Cobb and Lazard, as well as Rodgers’ trusted coaching mind in Nathaniel Hackett, there’s no one in New York better equipped to make things at least somewhat resemble a Rodgers-led group than Boyle.

Even with their drastic gulf in playing time, Boyle said that he has formed an ironclad friendship with Rodgers, who mentioned that he “loved” the Connecticut/Eastern Kentucky alum before the latter made his first NFL start in 2021.

“We’re like-minded,” Boyle said of his relationship with Rodgers. “We have similar interests. We formulated that into a friendship, and it’s very near and dear to my heart.”

Don’t ditch the switch

Before we, or the Jets, go any further here, put aside the idea of the offense recovering well enough to convince Rodgers to come back and lead a playoff run. Switching quarterbacks, particularly if it’s Boyle, gives them at least a shot at such a fantasy, but hardly a guarantee. Unless Rodgers is getting the Avenger cocktail Steve Rogers was served approximately 30 Marvel movies ago, it’s best to keep him on the shelf.

Sitting Wilson offers Saleh and his staff a true example of accountability. Saleh has made his green living as a so-called “players’ coach,” and the approach that was downright necessary after the frequent paranoia and suspicions of the Adam Gase era. That they actually tried to build a plan to help Wilson right the ship is a refreshing concept in the unforgiving arena of NFL transactions.

But the fact that Saleh keeps inserting Wilson in games that still have some semblance of meaning to the Jets can’t be wise or strong for team morale. Playing in green and white, even in a relatively hopeful period on the franchise timeline, is a stressful endeavor. Players who come to help the team win want and need assurance that those in charge will do what is necessary when it comes to pressing forward.

It’s increasingly clear that Wilson, despite his fleeting flashes of brilliance, is not that answer. Removing him from the equation, even if only for a short while, would be a strong showcase of accountability to Saleh. It’s clear that young Wilson has left a sizable impact on Saleh, who is perhaps one of the few left in New York that wants to see him succeed. Removing the supposed favorite for his shortcomings would be an undoubted commitment to the cause and perhaps even solidify his continued wearing of the Jets sideline’s top headset.

Boyle offers temporary relief at best. But, as it stands, the Jets have none on the way if they keep going the way they’re going.

Geoff Magliocchetti is on X @GeoffJMags

Want More Jet X?

Subscribe to become a Jet X Member to unlock every piece of Jets X-Factor content (film breakdowns, analytics, Sabo with the Jets, etc.), get audio versions of each article, receive the ability to comment within our community, and experience an ad-free platform experience.

Download the free Jet X Mobile App to get customizable notifications directly to your iOS (App Store) or Android (Google Play) device.

Sign up for Jet X Daily, our daily newsletter that's delivered to your inbox every morning at 8:00 a.m. ET.

Add Jets X-Factor to your Google News feed and/or find us on Apple News to stay updated with the New York Jets.

Follow us on X (Formerly Twitter) @jetsxfactor for all the latest New York Jets news, Facebook for even more, Instagram for some of the top NY Jets images, and YouTube for original Jets X-Factor videos.

Related Articles

About the Author

More From Author


Notify of
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
8 months ago

23 of 36, 263 yards. 0TD and 1INT (yes at a horrible time) 4 rushes for 54 yards. You think you are getting more out of Timmy? How about this: STOP thinking of Zach the same way you did last season. They admitted he’s not ready, and may never be the lead guy when they brought Rogers in here. We ALL agreed Zach’s problems were at least a year to fix, and maybe 2, so Rogers got hurt on play 4 and you expected Zach to be fixed?

Listen he’s not been great, but he’s getting ZERO help. Not from the WR’s, the OL, the play caller, and now it seems they can’t have a big play without penalties. He’s not a guy that can cover up a team’s mistakes, or can carry the load if guys are injured, why do you insist on expecting that of him? Yes, I know he was the #2 pick but that storyline ended when the brought in Rogers. Right now, he’s the backup QB and if Timmy put up those numbers you’d be giddy.

This is a collection of “not good enough” it’s not as if everybody is playing great and the QB isn’t.

Last edited 8 months ago by Jets71
Jonathan Richter
8 months ago

Do you even read what you write?

“Rodgers, Patrick Mahomes, or Tom Brady himself would have trouble succeeding behind the Jets’ makeshift offensive line.”

Timmy Time!”

8 months ago

Let me just say for the record that I was DEAD set against letting Mike White leave. That right there was up with their many historically dumbest moves.

Jonathan Richter
8 months ago
Reply to  Bird9

Mike White would haver been on IR a long time ago with this O line.

8 months ago

I agree, and if we are being honest they didn’t win more when White played. It would have been the same thing. He would be hurt.