The New York Jets still have seven games left in their 2026 season, but much of the discussion among the team’s fanbase has shifted toward what seems like a likely head-coaching search this offseason.

At this point, it feels that only a miracle can protect the Jets’ current 5-22 head coach, Aaron Glenn.

Two of the “bigger fish” linked to the Jets โ€” not necessarily through reporting, but based on timelines โ€” have been former Pittsburgh Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin and former Buffalo Bills boss Sean McDermott.

Obviously, both Tomlin and McDermott are highly established head coaches. In a hypothetical world, suppose both are willing to take the Jets’ top job…

Who would make more sense for Gang Green?

McDermott or Tomlin?

Let’s start with McDermott. While many folks remember him for not getting the Bills over the hump, it’s important to look back to when he began his tenure in Orchard Park, N.Y.

When he took over in 2017, Buffalo hadn’t made the playoffs since 1999. That season, he brought the Bills to the postseason. Buffalo had a longer playoff drought than the Jets’ current 15-plus-year skid, and McDermott came in and broke it right away.

That alone is intriguing. McDermott has experience rescuing a division rival right away that was almost certainly in a rougher spot than the Jets’ future outlook.

Overall, McDermott’s eight-year run with the Bills produced seven playoff berths and two appearances in the AFC Championship game (2020 and 2024). He owns an 8-8 record in the postseason while having five division championships to his name, all of which came consecutively.

Oh, he also helped oversee Josh Allen’s development, who is arguably the league’s best quarterback and the reigning MVP. That’s another important distinction.

Just because McDermott isn’t an offensive-minded head coach doesn’t mean he didn’t play a significant role in Allen’s development.

As Jets fans know firsthand, the supporting cast, both on the field and on the sideline, for a young quarterback is instrumental. That’s even more true for someone like Allen, who was very raw at the time.

JET XFan Poll
NEXT HEAD COACH ยท NOV 20

Which Head Coach should the Jets hire?

Choose your next head coach ยท Hypothetical hiring choices

McDermott hired Brian Daboll, who played a crucial role in Allen’s early success. When Daboll was poached by the New York Giants, he promoted Ken Dorsey. He then appropriately turned to Joe Brady, who later replaced him as Buffalo’s head coach.

Despite having Allen, McDermott didn’t like the Bills’ offensive direction midway through 2023. Following a 5-5 start to the year, he fired Dorsey and promoted Brady. That move led to a 6-1 finish to the regular season, including an AFC East title.

McDermott deserves tremendous credit for that. If he hadn’t made the gutsy decision to fire Dorsey after his act started to sour, who knows if Allen would ever get the chance to reach the next level he has with Brady.

Overall, the Jets’ next head coach needs to understand how to put a young quarterback in position to succeed, and McDermott has already played a crucial role in that process.

Tomlin’s case

I have all the respect in the world for Tomlin. No losing seasons over 19 years with the Steelers don’t happen by accident. He is clearly one of the best coaches to come out of the league, ranking top 10 in regular-season wins by HCs in NFL history.

However, I’m not convinced that he should be the Jets’ “all-in” or No. 1 option. One of the biggest reasons behind that has to do with his record, or lack thereof, when it comes to developing quarterbacks.

Let me preface this by saying Tomlin did a lot of things well in Pittsburgh. He consistently kept them competitive and helped develop elite defensive players like T.J. Watt and Cameron Hayward, but he didn’t develop a quarterback.

By the time Tomlin got the job, Ben Roethlisberger was already established. When his time came, Tomlin and the Steelers organization struggled to find a consistent option.

Selecting Kenny Pickett in the first round turned out to be a complete mistake, and he was out of Pittsburgh after two years. Now, that’s not completely Tomlin’s fault. The front office certainly deserves a fair share of blame there, too.

My point is that he hasn’t developed a quarterback. That is what the Jets need most right now, given where they stand entering 2027: someone who can develop a young QB.

That’s not to say Tomlin can’t do it; we just haven’t seen it before. He also cycled through three offensive coordinators during his final five years with the Steelers.

There’s also the organizational component. Who’s to say that he would come in and stack winning seasons with the Jets year after year as he did in Pittsburgh?

Tomlin is just one of four head coaches the Steelers have employed since 1969. The Jets, on the other hand, have had six since 2010.

Those are two completely different environments. There is no guarantee he could replicate his Pittsburgh success in New York.

There is obviously no guarantee that either one would come to the Big Apple and immediately find success with the Jets. In head coaching searches, it’s largely been a matter of luck. Coaches pan out for several reasons, some of which are beyond their control.

Based on track record and career history, though, Sean McDermott seems to be the cleaner fit over Mike Tomlin.