The New York Jets have struggled throughout the 2026 season, but they mostly stayed out of No. 1 pick conversationsโuntil now.
With a four-game losing streak and an upcoming matchup against the 1-8 Los Angeles Chargers, the 2-8 Jets are now squarely in the mix to earn the first overall pick in the 2027 NFL draft. If they lose to Los Angeles on Sunday, the Jets could hold the top selection by the end of the day, depending on other results around the league.
Should the Jets lose at SoFi Stadium (the same building where their No. 1 pick hopes were dashed six years ago) to enter the No. 1 pick sweepstakes, a major question will begin to loom over them.
The potential decision facing New York
We all know that the Jets need a franchise quarterback.
But the best player in the 2027 draft class isn’t a quarterback.
It’s Ohio State wide receiver Jeremiah Smith.
A 20-year-old prodigy from Hollywood, Florida, Smith has been destined for greatness since he was the nation’s No. 1 overall recruit in the 2024 class. Since joining the Buckeyes, Smith has done nothing but live up to those expectations. As an 18-year-old true freshman in 2024, Smith racked up 76 receptions for 1,315 yards and 15 touchdowns in 16 games.
Smith took a leap in his sophomore season, collecting 87 receptions for 1,243 yards and 12 touchdowns in 13 games. This year, he has leaped once again, posting 80 receptions for 1,317 yards and 15 touchdowns in 10 games.
Widely considered a slam-dunk NFL star (not that this truly exists, but he is as close as it gets), the 6-foot-4, 223-pound superhuman playmaker is the rare wide receiver prospect worthy of the No. 1 pick. Not only is he great enough to be considered in that slot, but he is so far ahead of the rest of the class that it would be mildly surprising if he was not chosen first overallโbarring a quarterback-needy team passing on him to reach for a signal-caller.
That’s where the Jets come in.
The Jets badly need a franchise quarterback. Meanwhile, wide receiver might be the strongest position on their roster. Garrett Wilson is the best player on the team, while Omar Cooper Jr. and Adonai Mitchell have also been among New York’s best performers this year. Both are under 25 years old and signed beyond 2026.
That should make quarterback the no-brainer preference if the Jets land the first pick. However, if the Jets were to take a quarterback over Smith, it would be a major reach in terms of talent relative to position.
This is not expected to be a strong quarterback class, contrary to the hype that was drummed up over the past year. The 2026 college football season revealed warts in many of the top prospects, while some were injured.
Oklahoma State’s Drew Mestemaker, whom Jets general manager Darren Mougey watched in-person a few weeks back, is emerging as the top quarterback prospect. At NFL Mock Draft Database, Mestemaker has skyrocketed to the No. 2 overall spot on the consensus big board, right behind Smith. On Aug. 20, he was No. 31, and as recently as Oct. 10, he was No. 17.
Mestemaker is a solid quarterback prospect, but he is nowhere near the quarterback that Smith is a wide receiver. Just a year ago, he was playing at North Texas. To his credit, he has been crushing it since transferring to Oklahoma State, but he isn’t without his share of bright red flags.
Ball security is a massive problem for the Cowboys quarterback. Mestemaker has the second-most turnover-worthy throws in all of college football (20), trailing only Hawaii’s Micah Alejado. He is also alarmingly prone to missing layups; Mestemaker has an adjusted completion percentage (which accounts for drops, throwaways, batted passes, etc.) of 75.4% on short throws, which are any passes from 0-9 yards downfield. That ranks 119th out of 142 qualified FBS quarterbacks.
This is not to say that Mestemaker’s potential does not make him worthy of consideration for the No. 1 pick; his arm strength and accuracy on deep throws is nothing short of remarkable, and he is an excellent playmaker on the move. His ceiling is high, and quarterbacks are drafted early for what they could be, not what they are.
The question, though, is whether a late-rising quarterback prospect who needs immense development in certain areas should be selected over one of the most flawless non-quarterback prospects to ever enter the draft.
The matter is complicated even further by the Jets’ strength at wide receiver.
Of course, though, the Jets will have another high first-round pick courtesy of the Indianapolis Colts, so choosing Smith would not prevent the Jets from leaving the top 10 without a quarterback. That’s what makes the idea of choosing Smith appealing, as opposed to a scenario where they only had their own first-round pick.
The risk, however, is that instead of choosing whichever quarterback they’d please, they would have to see how the board falls and settle for the best quarterback remaining. They may even have to trade up just to make that happen.
Perhaps it’s best to save a deep dive into this topic for another day, as the Jets still have seven games to play, with two massive draft-related contests coming up. If the Jets defeat Los Angeles on Sunday, they will never be mentioned in the same sentence as Smith again (unless he goes to the Dolphins and tears them up twice a year).
Nonetheless, it’s fascinating to think about the potential implications of Sunday’s game. If the Jets lose, they will set themselves up to push for the top draft pick, which is promising for their future, but it’s not as if they would have a clear-cut prize waiting for them, such as in 2021, when Trevor Lawrence was coming out. Rather, the Jets would be faced with making one the toughest calls at No. 1 in recent memory.

