The average National Football League play lasts just four to six seconds, which means instincts and tendencies are what shine over that extremely short span. Granted, what happens during a play can feature smarts, but mid-play smarts are almost always due to pre-play preparation.
This pre-play time includes everything that came before it. The weekly game plan qualifies, as does a player’s football experience. Play after play, the football instinctual bank continues to grow, with both positive and negative additions.
These days, what an offense or defense does pre-snap, while at the line of scrimmage, is crucial. The quarterback diagnoses the defense’s alignment, while the Mike continuously calls out checks, as both units seek a strategic advantage.
Just don’t make the mistake of thinking it’s only about positioning, leverage, or anything else related to strategic wits from an Xs and Os perspective.
The human element is overwhelmingly consequential.
This is an idea the 2026 New York Jets defense should fully comprehend.
Instilling ideas
Once upon a time, pro quarterbacks had to be extremely careful when throwing the ball into certain areas of the field. Not only did quarterbacks have to avoid certain areas in specific situations, but they also understood what the consequences of a mistake could mean.
For instance, former Los Angeles Rams quarterback Jim Everett knew what he could and couldn’t do against the San Francisco 49ers. (Longtime media personality Jim Rome is now acutely aware of what he can ask Everett, but that’s an entirely different story for another day.)
Ronnie Lott played for the Niners, which meant one mistake on a dig route could equal a trip to the hospital for one of his receivers.
Not only did Lott intimidate the opposition โ which legitimately forced some receivers to shy away from the middle of the field โ but his presence limited what offenses could do against his defense. Sure, quarterbacks and weapons hardly have to worry about the hard-hitting safety anymore, but that doesn’t mean the human element is completely gone from the sport.
Even in today’s less physical version of football, a certain mentality is required โ at least a sufficient level of the right mentality.
Josh Allen’s fearless day
When an offensive player is doing whatever he wants against a defense, at some point, something needs to happen. When a quarterback is skipping through the park on a bright sunny day, each time a designed quarterback rushing concept is called, again, something must … go … down.
Each time Josh Allen broke the huddle and did his at-the-line thing in the Buffalo Bills’ 31-12 victory in Week 10, he felt like no consequences would be coming his way.
Allen didn’t have a particularly impressive day. He only threw for 196 yards and a touchdown (to an interception) on 11 of 22 passing, and he only compiled a meager 5 yards on as many attempts.
But it’s not the stats that matter; it’s the willingness to attempt certain actions an offense should think twice about.
Allen tallied two touchdowns and multiple critical first downs on those five carries. Worse yet, Buffalo had no qualms about calling those plays when necessary.
Allen himself had no fear about running quarterback sneaks when required, and even taking a designed quarterback rush up the A-gap for a critical Bills’ touchdown in the third quarter:
Can somebody please smack him in the ribs?
This New York Jets defense is completely devoid of violence and grittiness.
A legit mindset matters
At no point did Josh Allen have to fear anything the Jets defense had to offer. It’s one thing not to stop Allen’s designed quarterback rushes โ as most defenses fail to do โ but it’s another to repeatedly fail to make the opponent pay for their transgressions.
If the offense is exposing the quarterback too often, there must be punishment. It’s really that simple, even in today’s far less physical NFL.
We’re not talking about the attempt to hospitalize players, either. We’re instead talking about football hits โ a stick, a crown-to-the-chin-type pop, a wrap, and a drive that sends the offensive player backward or in a way that isn’t natural.
Not only does this Jets defense routinely give up far too much dirty/hidden yardage, but they also rarely make a legitimate tackle that stops the ball carrier in his tracks. Forget about driving the ball-carrier backward; that would take a mini-miracle at this point.
This example shows linebacker Jamien Sherwood not attacking, which leads to an additional five yards after first contact:
Against a defense that brings a semblance of violence and grittiness to the table, a quarterback would be forced to bring a different mindset to the table. Whether it’s in his subconscious or in the forefront, the human remembers the bad feeling previously and/or recently experienced.
A quarterback who remembers the rib shot from the side, on the previously designed run up the gut, is suddenly a bit more clouded in his own mindset and judgment when carrying out the play.
It’s that intimidation and experiential factor that nobody can ever jot down on paper and display as a stat. Yet, it’s as real as anything in football.
This New York Jets defense doesn’t just need an overhaul in the talent department; it needs core building blocks to help establish a legitimate mindset.
But hey, at least there was one solid hit in the Buffalo game:

