Another year, another lost New York Jets season in which Garrett Wilson shines nonetheless.
No matter how many losses the Jets stockpile in his career, Wilson continues to impress the world his penchant for physics-defying catches.
Focusing on areas within his control, Wilson has clearly been one of the NFL’s best wide receivers this year, regardless of his box-score statistics in a flawed offense. In metrics like drop rate (3.8%), contested-catch rate (62.5%), catch rate over expected (6.7%), and open score (league-best 85), Wilson has been among the cream of the crop.
Still, there’s one Infinity Stone left for Garrett Wilson to add to his game in 2026: yards after the catch.
While Wilson is getting open at will and catching just about everything thrown his way, he hasn’t done much after the catch this season. Wilson is tied for 45th among wide receivers in yards after the catch (123) and ranks 54th with just two missed tackles forced.
This is a major drop-off for him. The 2.5 YAC per reception is a career-low, more than a yard below his career average of 3.8. The drop-off in missed tackles forced is even larger; for his career, Wilson is averaging 0.197 missed tackles forced per reception, compared to 0.040 this year, barely over 20% of his career average. For perspective, the 2026 league average for wide receivers is 0.117, so Wilson’s 2022-25 average was substantially above-average for the position.
Wilson’s career-low for missed tackles forced is nine, and that was in 2025, when he played seven games. On a per-game basis, his career-low is 1.0 missed tackle forced per game, coming back in 2023, when he had 17 in 17 games. Right now, Wilson is averaging 0.2 per game, putting him on pace to finish the 2026 season with about four missed tackles forced.
Part of the drop-off comes from a change in Wilson’s role. Under offensive coordinator Frank Reich, Wilson is being used in the most traditional X receiver role of his career, similar to previous receivers who played under Reich, like the Eagles’ Alshon Jeffery and the Colts’ T.Y. Hilton. In this role, Wilson is playing a career-high 77.5% of his snaps out wide, and his average target is coming a career-high 11.5 yards downfield.
Simply put, Wilson’s role is more vertical-centric than ever before, which certainly hurts his YAC potential. He is running more go routes and out routes, which are less conducive to YAC. When Wilson was lining up in the slot more often and generally being targeted closer to the line of scrimmage, he was getting more targets on crossers and digs, which are more YAC-conducive.
The Jets have also all but removed Wilson from their screen game; he has been targeted on one screen this season. Last year, he saw just two screens in seven games, but back in 2024, the Jets threw him 18 screens in 17 games, with those plays producing 107 YAC and six missed tackles forced. So, a large part of the lost YAC production comes from the reduction in screens.
However, even after accounting for the changes in his role, it’s still fair to say that Wilson is capable of better playmaking with the ball in his hands.
NFL Pro tracks a metric called “yards after catch over expected” (YACOE). Using GPS tracking data, it estimates how many yards after the catch a pass-catcher is expected to gain on each play based on where he catches it, what type of route it was, how close the nearest defenders are, the angles of those defenders, and so on.
This season, Wilson has accumulated -3 YACOE, which essentially means he has gained three fewer yards after the catch than expected. That’s a marginal amount below zero, so, essentially, he’s gained about what he’d be expected to. This paints a much less troubling picture than his drastic drop-offs in raw YAC and missed tackles forced; YACOE is doing a good job of accounting for the lower YAC expectations of his new role.
However, up-to-par YAC performance is below what Wilson is capable of. Over his first four seasons, Wilson racked up 172 total YACOE, averaging out to 0.55 yards per reception and 3.0 yards per game. Those extra hidden yards from after-the-catch elusiveness can make the difference in a football game.
It is worth nothing, though, that Wilson’s YACOE performance has gradually declined from year to year:
- 2022: 86
- 2023: 53
- 2024: 36
- 2025: -3
- 2026: -3
Is Wilson’s YAC decline more than just a role change? Might he not be the same after-the-catch playmaker that he was as a rookie?
It’s possible, given the year-over-year trajectory. But it could also be a fluke that Wilson is due to rebound from over the final seven games.
Even if Wilson remains a middling YAC player, though, he has been so dominant in the separation and pass-catching departments this year that he remains an upper-echelon weapon.
But if Wilson wants to unequivocally place himself among the league’s elite wideouts, returning to his peaks as an after-the-catch playmaker would go a long way. If he can get back to the elite ranks in this area, there wouldn’t be a significant hole in his game.

