Home | Articles | Column | Ranking the top detractors of NY Jets QB Aaron Rodgers

Ranking the top detractors of NY Jets QB Aaron Rodgers

C.J. Stroud, Aaron Rodgers, Texans, NY Jets
C.J. Stroud, Houston Texans, New York Jets, Getty Images

Listing all the people who have ripped the New York Jets quarterback

New York Jets quarterback Aaron Rodgers is no stranger to haters, particularly in the media. Still, even for him, the vitriol aimed in his direction this offseason has been overkill.

Or maybe it’s just that there’s nothing better to talk about, making the barbs more noticeable.

Either way, it’s entertaining to turn the haters into a list of the best Rodgers detractors. Who has done the best job of attacking the Jets quarterback this offseason?

Dishonorable mentions

Kurt Warner claimed that Rodgers is not in the all-time GOAT conversation because he has only one Super Bowl. This is a more typical debate point about Rodgers and isn’t necessarily a personal knock.

Former Packers receiver Amari Rodgers showed his sour grapes when he commented “If only [I] had this type of love coming into GB, but to each his own!” in response to the report that Malachi Corley was getting personal attention from Aaron Rodgers.

The Detroit Tigers’ Jumbotron exulted over the fact that a little-known special teamer had more completed passes than Rodgers. It was certainly tasteless.

10. Jason La Canfora

9. Shaun who?

For his career, Shaun King posted a 27:24 TD:INT ratio. His most memorable moment in reference to the Jets was being the losing quarterback of the Keyshawn revenge game, a 21-17 Jets comeback victory in 2000 after trailing 17-6 at the two-minute warning.

A player with that kind of resumé, who has faded into oblivion after his career much as he was obscure during it, still took the opportunity to rip Rodgers.

“Robert Saleh is obviously on the hot seat. What more could you do to undermine the soft footing that he’s already on than to miss the mandatory minicamp?”

King added that Rodgers knew when minicamp would be right when the 2023 season ended. He called Rodgers “selfish” for choosing to miss minicamp rather than reschedule his other engagement.

Of course, King undermined his whole premise by claiming that Rodgers needed time to work with Mike Williams. As anyone who’s even semi-aware of what’s going on around the Jets knows, Williams is still sidelined by his ACL tear and was not on the field for mandatory minicamp.

At least get the facts right.

8. Matt Miller

Upon the news that Rodgers missed the Jets’ mandatory minicamp:

7. Nick Wright

6. ESPN in on the act

Dan Graziano of ESPN is a familiar face in the bash Rodgers media. He called Rodgers a “narcissistic con artist” during the NFL playoffs, per The New York Post.

Most recently, regarding Rodgers missing minicamp, Graziano said, “No, it’s not an overreaction. Thirty-one starting quarterbacks made their mandatory minicamp. It’s another Aaron Rodgers thing. So far in his time with the Jets, he has not made a contribution to winning (which is a phrase I borrowed from him), and he has been a distraction. He’s been all about everything else.”

5. Shannon not-so-Sharpe

Shannon Sharpe claims he’s been telling us all for a decade that Rodgers is “selfish” and “does not care about the team.” Co-host Chad Johnson added that he feels bad for Garrett Wilson.

4. Continuing nemesis

Long-time Patriots receiver Julian Edelman was a thorn in the Jets’ side as a player, posting 79 catches for 855 yards and 5 touchdowns in 17 matchups. He passed that mantle on to his post-playing-days self when he went on the hunt for Rodgers’ blood.

“I think it’s a bad look for your leader, for whatever reason, to go and miss (a mandatory minicamp). I was with Tom Brady in his 25th year or 23rd year, and he started missing OTAs here and there, but he never missed a mandatory minicamp. I just thought it was a bad look.”

Edelman added that other players are likely upset about Rodgers’ absence and if the Jets start 1-3, it’s going to be a major distraction.

It’s worth noting who Edelman was talking to, though — which brings us to the king of all the Rodgers haters.

3. Following the herd

Colin Cowherd’s loathing of Rodgers has reached obscene heights. I don’t think it’s even possible to list all the different times and ways he’s ripped the Jets quarterback this offseason. This is what he had to say back in May: “Aaron is a pretty prickly old quarterback with maybe one year left. I think he’s absolutely past his prime.”

Cowherd also called Rodgers’ attempted return in 2023 a “PR grift” and claimed that Rodgers will “soon be irrelevant.”

Maybe calling Cowherd’s show “The Herd” makes sense since that’s what he’s followed when it comes to the Rodgers narrative.

2. C.J. Stroud

In some ways, C.J. Stroud’s attack on Rodgers was the most disrespectful, as it went to the heart of who he is as a quarterback. It’s one thing to say Rodgers is not in the GOAT conversation due to having only one ring, but it’s a different ballgame to prefer the career of the mediocre Eli Manning over Rodgers’. To say Matthew Stafford would have won more rings in the same situation is even more slander.

Stroud’s approach was wrong, but it’s the disrespect that a second-year passer with 23 regular-season touchdown passes under his belt showed for one of the best quarterbacks of all time that puts him at this spot.

Oh, and for a player whose biggest struggles as a rookie came against the Jets, it might not have been the wisest course of action.

1. Pro Football Talk

If there’s anyone who hates Rodgers more than Cowherd, it’s Mike Florio of Pro Football Talk. Just type in “Mike Florio Aaron Rodgers” into YouTube, and you’ll get segment after segment of Florio ripping on Rodgers. For example, he sarcastically commented that Rodgers “probably wouldn’t be on the logo of the National Football League.”

In another segment, he referenced Edelman’s shot, claiming that it would sting for Rodgers, coming as it did from a player who has as many Super Bowl MVPs as he does, more than it would coming from the media. Then he went off on a bit of a tangent about Rodgers.

“It’s easy to dismiss the haters. Anyone in the media who would dare question Aaron Rodgers is ‘corrupted by Big Pharma’ or otherwise evil. He’s got this weird, everything is binary, good-evil. … He’s got it all twisted into ‘he’s Frodo, we’re the Dark Lord, he’s Luke Skywalker and we’re Darth Vader.’ Maybe he’s Darth Vader.”

Most recently, in an indirect but clear shot at Rodgers, Florio ranked the Jets’ roster 25th in the NFL.

Want More Jet X?

Subscribe to become a Jet X Member to unlock every piece of Jets X-Factor content (film breakdowns, analytics, Sabo with the Jets, etc.), get audio versions of each article, receive the ability to comment within our community, and experience an ad-free platform experience.

Download the free Jet X Mobile App to get customizable notifications directly to your iOS (App Store) or Android (Google Play) device.

Sign up for Jet X Daily, our daily newsletter that's delivered to your inbox every morning at 8:00 a.m. ET.

Add Jets X-Factor to your Google News feed and/or find us on Apple News to stay updated with the New York Jets.

Follow us on X (Formerly Twitter) @jetsxfactor for all the latest New York Jets news, Facebook for even more, Instagram for some of the top NY Jets images, and YouTube for original Jets X-Factor videos.

Related Articles

About the Author

More From Author


Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments